
By David Baughan
One of my first jobs in Canada, after arriving from London in
the late 1990s, was working on the set of the Road to Avonlea
television series in Toronto. Many of the crew and cast members
had been involved in this production for years and were like
family members; it reminded me of English soap operas such
as Coronation Street. I had never heard of Anne of Green
Gables and was intrigued to hear of its so called importance
to Canadian culture. I tried reading the early 20th century
novels but found them asinine and sugar-coated. I struggled
to understand why they were so significant, because to me,
they were on a par with Enid Blyton stories. Of course Sullivan
Entertainment does an amazing job of popularizing its
"Anne" television series but still, a Canadian icon?
Now as I analyze the phenomenon again I begin to understand
Anne's relevance to Canadian culture. She filled a void for
immigrants of belonging (within a new province and new
family) and provided a sense of home - a feeling of familiarity
and comfort. According to Elizabeth DeBlois, the director of
the L. M. Montgomery Institute at the University of Prince
Edward Island, the only academic institute for a Canadian
novelist: "In a sense, everybody can identify with something
in Anne's world. We're not all orphans, thank goodness, but a
lot of people can sympathize with the things she's looking for
in life because they're things everybody wants. She wants a
home. She wants people to love her and she wants friends.
Who doesn't want those things? It's a universal message."
I found there was a wide discrepancy between the reactions
of men and women to the novels. On the one hand many
male readers said they were trivial and not relevant to their
own experiences, but on the other hand, women described
them as important and supportive, particularly during their
most formative years. Was this another sign of men being out
of touch with their feminine side or are the books specifically
aimed at women as central to the idea of home?
There is no question that those who do support Anne often
do so strongly and passionately. "I never did see Anne as a
goody two-shoes because any kid who takes a slate and slams
it over somebody's head because of their temper can't be,"
says Megan Follows, who at the age of 16 played Anne
Shirley in the Anne of Green Gables TV movies. She also
disagrees with those who dismiss Anne as a pretty period
piece. A self-described Wizard of Oz fan who only read Anne
of Green Gables when she auditioned for the role, Follows
believes Anne's story tackles the challenges of gender and
class. "It's easy to put a Pollyanna stamp on Anne, but I think
it's a generalization which does a disservice to what Lucy
Maud wrote. The sense of the authoritative voice of the elders,
or the rigid black-and-white environment that that child
comes into, is not romanticized. What that little girl does out
of necessity, and for her survival, is create an extremely rich
inner life. And it's her saving grace. It saves her when she's up
against a tremendous amount of rejection, and what she falls
back on - and what I would imagine is what Lucy Maud
herself fell back on - is her creative spirit and the fact that
she could see a tremendous amount of beauty in times and
environments that could have been quite stark."
It has been said that Anne has a feminist edge too and former
Governor General Adrienne Clarkson, who is on the international
advisory board of the L. M. Montgomery Institute, agrees: "I
think it is a feminist book. Anne makes sacrifices in the book.
Anne does not go straight on to teachers' college because
Marilla is left alone when Matthew dies and she decides she'll
stay home and help Marilla. But that in no way holds her up
because later on she goes to college after she's got everything
settled. She manages to make that balance between the
personal and the professional, which is still a lesson to
everyone." Clarkson says that at age 10, "I identified with her.
To me she was somebody who helped me - and I think does
help a lot of immigrants' children - understand what Canada
was like."
Canada's immigration policies in the 19th century were highly
restrictive and based on racial discrimination. The main purpose
of the legislation was to restrict certain races or groups from
entering the country. For example, the 1885 Chinese Immigration
Act was an attempt to restrict Chinese immigration by
placing a head tax on every immigrant from the Chinese
mainland. Those who were allowed to immigrate in the 19th
century kept to themselves and held on to their traditions
and culture. It was only later in the 20th century that the
federal government encouraged multiculturalism, to be
followed by an attempt at integration. Those arriving in the
19th and early twentieth centuries in fairly isolated areas,
such as Prince Edward Island (PEI), clung to their previous lives
and found comfort in the sense of belonging that came from
their shared histories. The strong sense of church, school,
storytelling and book learning were brought over from
Scotland. In her novels Montgomery continues this tradition
and builds upon it. Thus an immigrant arriving from afar, or
even a young girl from an orphanage, can take comfort in
finding the sense of a homeland and a feeling of belonging
to both a family and the province as a whole.
Samantha Currie who plays
Anne in this production says
about her character: "I think
she has so many qualities that
are appealing to so many
people. I find her very magical,
inquisitive, intelligent, full of
faults (making her VERY
relatable), joyful and
unintentionally funny. She
represents the child in all of us.
And maybe she is compelling
or loved because she is so
relatable. We want her to
succeed. Feeling her heartache,
love, joys and defeats, she and
the other characters of the
story take us right along with
them, sharing their adventures
and their way of life . . . a little
slice of what might have been."
When Montgomery published
her first novel, Anne of Green
Gables in 1908, it became an
almost instant bestseller in
Canada and the work has
remained in print for just over
a century in English as well as
in many other languages. She
published 22 novels and books
of short stories, as well as a
poetry book, and a brief
autobiography. She left
behind many published and
unpublished articles written
for various magazines.
Thousands of tourists visit PEI
annually to see the "sacred
sites" of the novels and the
imagined landscapes. A
concomitant industry exists in
Anne-related commodities
that adds to the televised
series, a musical and an
animated series.
In 1923 Montgomery became the first Canadian woman to
become a Fellow of the Royal Society for the Encouragement
of Arts, Manufactures and Commerce (RSA) in the United
Kingdom. In 1935 she was elected to L'institute de France
and in the same year received an Order of the British Empire
(OBE). Montgomery was declared a person of national historic
significance in 1943 and for many people L. M. Montgomery
is Canada. There is no escaping the fact that Anne is a force
to be reckoned with!